China Does Not Exist
Green European JournalIn the so-called West, dominant ideological narratives about China’s rise as a global power say very little about China itself. Rather, as is often the case in the history of propaganda, they reflect the interests, aspirations, fears, and anxieties of the societies that produce them. To move beyond the default position of ideological and geopolitical competition with China and confront the fascist tide, we need to draw on the lesser-known emancipatory tradition of propaganda.
In the so-called West, dominant ideological narratives about China’s rise as a global power say very little about China itself. Rather, as is often the case in the history of propaganda, they reflect the interests, aspirations, fears, and anxieties of the societies that produce them. To move beyond the default position of ideological and geopolitical competition with China and confront the fascist tide, we need to draw on the lesser-known emancipatory tradition of propaganda.
This article will feature in the Green European Journal’s winter 2026 print edition Far West: Europe in the “Chinese Century”. Subscribe now and be among the first to receive a copy in December.
Central to all propaganda is the construction of an “us-versus-them” dichotomy. One of the earliest, and vilest, examples of this in modern propaganda history is the film Der Ewige Jude (“The Eternal Jew”, 1940), based on an exhibition of the same title that toured Germany between 1937 and 1939. Its aim was to “inform” the German people of the supposed nature of “international Jewry”. It combined journalistic-looking footage with a voiceover and insidious editing in which Jewish families were intercut with images of rats and other vermin, suggesting a “plague” infecting German society and Europe at large.
The film contains an apparent paradox: Jewish people are, on one hand, depicted as a dirty, unhygienic infestation, and as tricksters and thieves, echoing the tropes that remain central to today’s antisemitic and anti-Roma propaganda. On the other hand, they are presented as intermarrying with the “Aryan” upper classes and holding increasing power in the global banking and financial sectors. The Rothschild family, a wealthy Jewish banking dynasty originating in Germany, became a central character in this narrative of “globalist Jewry.” Yet this growing power is also a communist project aiming to erase racial boundaries and national borders: on the poster of the film, the caricature of a Jewish person holds a world map branded with a hammer and sickle. But how can one be wretched and all-powerful, tenacious and weak, poor and rich, capitalist and communist, at the very same time?
A similar paradox runs through the work of propagandist and filmmaker Steve Bannon, once described by his fellow far-right ideologue Andrew Breitbart as the “Leni Riefenstahl of the Tea Party”. The film Generation Zero (2010), based on the book The Fourth Turning by William Strauss and Neil Howe, argues that every fourth American generation is faced with an existential crisis that requires the reassertion of white Christian economic nationalism (which later found its expression in Trumpism) to restore order and avoid societal collapse. At the root of the current crisis, according to Bannon, is an alliance that he would elaborate across his subsequent films, namely between the enemy within (the globalist elite spanning the Clinton Foundation, Jewish philanthropist George Soros, and the movements that they allegedly support, from Occupy to Black Lives Matter) and the enemy outside (“Islamic terrorism” and the Chinese Communist Party, which he considers the reincarnations of 20th-century totalitarianism).
Occupy Unmasked (2012) builds a fearful narrative around the Occupy movement, but it also depicts its members as slobs on welfare. It argues that George Soros controls the levers of power in international markets, but it also mocks the “snowflakes” receiving grants to attend his “woke” universities. It spins conspiracies framing Muslims and Chinese people as the greatest geopolitical threats since World War II, but it treats these faith and migrant communities as easy scapegoats at home.
The enemy, in Bannon’s pre-Trumpian articulation of Trumpism, is at once liberal and leftist, global capitalist and local socialist, secular and Islamist. Again, we face the question: how can all of these things be true of the same enemy at the same time?
The paradox is explained by the goal propaganda aims to achieve. If an enemy is too weak, it won’t activate a response; but if it is too powerful, its threat will paralyse rather than mobilise. The recipient of a propaganda message must be afraid, yet also be offered the chance to act heroically against the enemy, knowing that they can and will defeat it. What looks like a contradictory representation of the enemy is actually the necessary affective balance between fear and mobilisation.
But there is another explanation too. Jewish people can appear in multiple guises in Der Ewige Jude because, in the Nazis’ eyes, they are shapeshifters: poor one moment, communists or bankers the next. Jewish people can be all these things simultaneously because they have no essence. And if one has no essence, no core, no soul, then one is less human. The ethical dilemma of exterminating a whole people becomes far less troubling if they are not really human in the first place.
We see a similar dehumanising logic at play in the Gaza genocide today, where a whole people, including children, are recast as terrorists or terrorists in the making, and hospitals are framed as terrorist dens.
How can one be wretched and all-powerful, tenacious and weak, poor and rich, capitalist and communist, at the very same time?
Bannon contrasts his multifaceted and rootless enemy with the white Christian nationalists whose “blood and soil” credentials certify their belonging. If you are from nowhere, you are no one: not even human. In the US, we see the effect of those dehumanising narratives today in the mass incarceration, torture, and deportation of Black and brown people with the support of a significant portion of white Americans.
While Bannon, a spearheading figure in what Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor have termed “end times fascism”,1 has many affinities with the fascism of the Nazi Party, there are also clear differences in the depiction of the enemy and the societies each aimed to build. What matters here is the multifaceted and shapeshifting nature of the enemy, which characterises propaganda across conflicts and ideologies.

China: A narrative battle
Contemporary Western narratives about rival powers like China and Russia, not just on the far right but also in mainstream liberal media, share some of these characteristics.
Particularly since the beginning of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Russia has been depicted through two dominant categories. In the first, Russia suffers endless losses, its soldiers refuse to fight, its Soviet era weaponry is falling apart, its economy is on the verge of collapsing under pressure from economic sanctions, and no one dares to inform the president, Vladimir Putin, about the actual situation on the battlefield, which leads to increasingly disastrous decision-making. In the second, Russia poses an existential threat to Europe and the world at large, demanding a return to mandatory conscription and a bigger defence budget – even if it means spending less on housing, education, or health care.
The point here is not to assess the scale and nature of Putin’s ambitions, but to highlight a paradox: how can Russia be existentially dangerous and extremely weak at the same time? Once again, the enemy is all-powerful and all-weak.
In the case of China, too, liberal legacy media like the Guardian and The New York Times combine “totalitarian mockery” with existential risk. In the former, Xi Jinping bans Winnie the Pooh because memes have compared him to the cartoon bear; China introduces a social credit system, turning the country into a caricature of George Orwell’s 1984; Xi Jinping discusses eternal-life treatments with Putin to achieve dictator immortality.2 In the latter, China infiltrates our universities and companies to “steal” technology to win the AI race;3 it revives Mao-era political cult and defence strategies; it increases militarisation and poses a growing nuclear threat.
This dual representation of the Chinese threat, both ridiculous and existentially dangerous, teaches us very little about the social, political, and economic dynamics in a country that has nearly the landmass of Europe and has a population of about 1.4 billion.
For the MAGA coalition, figures like Putin or Xi Jinping become at once enemies and idols.
Moreover, with the increasing fascistisation of the US, another narrative is emerging with regard to China that is shared by part of the European far right. Trump still frames China as a “them” that threatens to replace the US as a key strategic, political, technological, and economic power. However, Trump also shows obsessive admiration for China’s “strongman” political hold, in contrast with the fragmented alliance he tries to keep together at home by inflicting extreme violence against its own population, from Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) deportations to attacks on democratic socialist figureheads like Somali-American congresswoman Ilhan Omar.
The “traditional” neocon approach to China, also pursued by the Biden administration, extended the old Cold War mentality to Beijing. But for the MAGA coalition, figures like Putin or Xi Jinping become at once enemies and idols. Trump’s vision is therefore one in which the US not only remains dominant politically and economically, but also imitates and outperforms what it considers Russia and China’s far more effective models of political control.
In MAGA propaganda, China remains a “hellhole”, as claimed by a post Trump shared on Truth Social,4 but it is also a “very tough” negotiator;5 Chinese people steal American jobs, but they are also the strongest business strategists; they “tend to be a little shorter”, but Xi is “very tall”, as Trump said after a recent visit.6 Here, threat and denigration go hand in hand with admiration and even envy. Trump wants to reconfigure what “us” means to make it resemble more closely what he thinks characterises the Chinese “them”.
Progressives, meanwhile, are caught between their own conflicting narratives about China. In the liberal worldview, collective interest can in no way constrain individual beliefs, expression, or identity, which leads to strong condemnation of Chinese-style social control. Progressives also tend to condemn the oppression of the Uyghur minority in Xinjiang and the repression of political opposition in Hong Kong in the name of human rights, while also trying to call out overly hawkish anti-Chinese propaganda.
Many progressives, both green and leftist, also praise China’s ability to keep market excesses in check and its massive investment in renewable energy, enabled by centralised state planning. At the same time, they reject state power when it expresses itself as a nationalistic, militarising force, for example over Taiwan.
As for socialists and radical leftists, they can’t make up their minds on whether China is ultimately socialist or capitalist. Is it just another capitalist superpower under the guise of “socialism with Chinese characteristics”, or is it the materialisation of their long-held aspirations?
In its more hopeful reading, this moment represents an opening into a world of radical diplomacy and realignment
The relevance of this question – does China belong to “us” or “them”? – signals the emergence of a multipolar world order, in which the illusion that liberal, capitalist democracy was ever the accepted global standard has crumbled, and in which liberal democracy is forced to face its own dark undercurrents, visible in the authoritarian turn sweeping across Europe and the US.
In its more hopeful reading, this moment represents an opening into a world of radical diplomacy and realignment – an opportunity to construct a more expansive “us”. But there is also a risk that simplistic dichotomies are reinforced rather than questioned.
Indeed, the liberal, MAGA, and, to some extent, progressive propaganda narratives on China show very little understanding of their supposed enemy or model. They are not based on what China is or does but are projections and assumptions, often used instrumentally for short-term political or economic interests.
For example, portraying the Chinese Communist Party as either a purely evil Leviathan to be fought or an effective central planner to take inspiration from prevents genuine understanding of the diverse currents within it, from hardcore Maoists to neoliberals.7 The same applies to China’s social credit system: when studied more closely, it looks less like a digital net of Black Mirror-style 8total control, and more like a selective and sector-specific system resembling credit-scoring systems used in the global financial sector.
None of this means we should glorify Chinese political and economic policies. But we should remember that they are not what dominant propaganda says they are.
Propagating radical peace
In the Western propaganda narratives analysed above, China has no existence of its own – it is only a mirror of the West’s own anxieties, projections, and interests. But China and the Chinese people exist – and they should exist in Western narrative formations, not as an a priori enemy or as a model to imitate, but as a subject with genuine interests and aspirations.
With our societies facing a dangerous descent towards fascism, extreme economic precarity, and climate collapse, we can no longer afford the kind of “us-versus-them” fuelling military and geopolitical competition. We have entered a hypervolatile world where failed harvests, megastorms and megafires, water scarcity, pandemics, and forced mass migration will increasingly be the norm.
In this context, we must relate to China and other nations and peoples through a different kind of propaganda – one that seeks to address the existential crises we face, rather than fuelling them. Planetary ecological policies, planetary wealth taxation, planetary AI regulation: none of these essential endeavours can be achieved by reducing China to the “them” side of a propaganda trope.
Many of the propaganda narratives analysed above belong to extreme authoritarian ideologies, but there is also a long history of what I refer to as “emancipatory propaganda”. In this history, the term does not signify mass manipulation or disinformation, but collective attempts to propagate a different reality based on common interests and liberation.
At the end of the 19th century, for example, the Filipino Propaganda Movement put forward a vision of independence and self-determination from Spanish colonial rule.9 In the early 20th century, writer Upton Sinclair declared the importance of artists joining socialist movements worldwide to “make a world”, that is, to imagine and shape a horizon of equality and cooperation beyond the darkness of feudal and monarchic society.
Sociologist and activist W.E.B. Du Bois, who laid the foundation for the civil rights movement, argued for the importance of “black propaganda”10 to propagate the struggle, dignity, culture, and victories of Black communities faced with normative white supremacist society. In the 1970s, writer and activist Lucy Lippard advocated the importance of “intimate feminist” propaganda to build deeper bonds against the isolation and fracturing created by mass media discourse.11 More recently, Donna Haraway has made the case for “multispecies propaganda” – telling stories of collective human and non-human co-existence and meaningful survival in the face of climate collapse.12
It is from these traditions that we must revisit dominant propaganda tropes, to imagine and strategise propagations of radical peace, cooperation, and coexistence. That doesn’t mean examining geopolitical forces uncritically or ignoring their contradictions. Rather, it is about imagining, composing, shaping – propagating – the largest imaginable “us” to defend the possibility of living worlds for all. In such propagation, China exists fully, as part of the existential endeavour to shape a world in which, instead of racing towards nuclear war and ecosystem breakdown, we collectively build the conditions for meaningful survival across nations, peoples, and species.
The only “us-versus-them” that matters now is the one between the defenders of radical peace and the coalitions of end times fascism.